Living Proof is the standard Priya Life Science now uses for its data stories. Every claim says what it stands on, every number can be recalculated on the reader's own device, the conclusion is tested in public, and the story keeps reporting after publication. The full rules are published as the Living Proof Standard.
It adds to the usual rules of journalism. It does not replace them. The first story written to it, Living Proof No. 1 on Ireland's clinical trials, went live on 15 November 2026.
Why we wrote a standard
Most data journalism asks readers to trust three things at once: that the numbers were calculated correctly, that the documents say what the reporter says they say, and that the finding would survive a different way of counting. The usual answer is a methods note at the end of the story. A reader can read it, but cannot test it.
We report on medicines, clinical trials and health spending in Ireland. These are subjects where a wrong number can mislead patients, clinicians and policymakers. So we decided that our data stories should hand over the working, not just describe it.
The five promises
The five promises are the summary. A story may carry the Living Proof name only if it meets every requirement in the standard, which has the full rules and a checklist, or says in its edition record which one it does not yet meet and why.
- Every claim says what it stands on. Each claim is marked as one of four kinds: Computed (our code calculated it from public data), Sourced (it comes from a document we read, linked and dated), Said (a named person said it on the record) or Our reading (our analysis, always labelled as such).
- Every number can be re-run by the reader. The data file is fingerprinted and archived with a DOI. The code is public. A button in the story downloads the same records and recalculates every published number in the reader's browser.
- The conclusion is attacked in public. We publish the other ways we tried to count, including any where the finding does not hold. We also state what evidence would change our mind.
- The story stays alive. A live layer, fed by our open data engine Airmid Éireann, reports what has changed since publication. The story shows its own age.
- Every change is visible. Corrections show the old value, the new value, the date and the reason, and are logged on our corrections page.
A story that breaks a requirement without saying so loses the Living Proof name until it is fixed.
What it looks like in the first story
Living Proof No. 1 asks whether Ireland is getting its share of clinical trials. It rests on 39 computed numbers, 11 sourced facts, one quotation and seven labelled readings. Its "Run the check" button downloads the 47,265 trial records behind the story, confirms the file has the same fingerprint as the archived copy, and recalculates every published number. The story tests its finding 18 other ways and shows the one comparison where it does not hold. Before publication we asked the Department of Health, the Health Research Board and the National Clinical Trials Office for a reply; the story says that none replied by the deadline and that any reply will be added with its date.
The story also admits where it falls short of its own standard. It was built before the standard was written, so there was no analysis plan dated before the numbers were run. Its edition record says so.
How it compares with existing codes
Living Proof sits on top of the codes journalists already follow, and we apply their principles of accuracy, fairness and the separation of fact and comment. Mentioning these codes does not mean Priya Life Science is a member or signatory of either body.
| Question | The usual standard | What Living Proof adds |
|---|---|---|
| Is it accurate? | The Press Council of Ireland Code, Principle 1: publications "shall strive at all times for truth and accuracy". | The reader can check the numbers themselves, on their own device, against an archived file. |
| Can I tell fact from comment? | Press Council Code, Principle 2, Distinguishing Fact and Comment. | Every sentence of analysis is labelled "Our reading" where it appears, not only in a separate opinion section. |
| Where does it come from? | The IFCN Code of Principles asks for sources "in enough detail that readers can replicate their work". | Each claim opens to its source, date and caveat, and the computed claims open to their formula and inputs. |
| How was it done? | The IFCN Code asks signatories to explain their methodology. | The method is the code itself, run on the page, with a stress test and a stated "what would change our mind". |
| What if it is wrong? | Press Council Code 1.2: significant errors "shall be corrected promptly and with due prominence". The IFCN asks for an open corrections policy. | Every correction shows the old and new value inside the story's edition record, as well as on the corrections page. |
| Is it still true? | Most stories are fixed on the day they are published. | A live layer reports new data after publication, labelled provisional until the next checked edition. |
How we use AI
We use AI tools, and we say exactly where. They help us find documents, write and test code, draft text that an editor then rewrites, and act as one extra reviewer. No number in a Living Proof story is produced by an AI model: every number is calculated by code from public files, and the reader's check is plain code that gives the same answer every time. No quotation is generated. A human editor reviews, verifies and approves every edition before it is published, and each story's edition record states how AI was used for that story.
What we build on
Others have pushed data journalism towards openness, and we credit them. Proof News puts an "ingredients label" on its stories. Newsrooms have long published their code and data, and Tomas Petricek's The Gamma project let readers see and change the code behind a chart. In May 2026 the data journalist S Anand proposed a "Verify" button for news stories, and in June 2026 researchers described Data2Story, in which AI agents link claims to data and re-run them. Living Proof combines four things we have not seen together in one published story: recalculation on the reader's device, typed evidence for every claim, a public stress test, and a live layer after publication.
Use it yourself
The standard, the engine and the data are open. The code is on GitHub under the EUPL-1.2 licence, and the data behind No. 1 is archived on Zenodo under CC BY 4.0. Newsrooms, researchers and students may reuse the format; please credit "Living Proof Standard, Priya Life Science" and link to the standard. Tell us about errors at info@priyalifescience.com.
Frequently asked questions
What does "re-runnable journalism" mean?
It means a reader can repeat the calculation behind each number in a story and get the same answer. In a Living Proof story this happens in the reader's own browser, from the same archived data file we used.
Does the check prove the story is true?
No. It proves that the published numbers follow from the published data and code. Whether the data measures the right thing is a separate question, which the stress test and the "what this cannot tell you" section address.
Is an AI model checking the numbers?
No. The check is ordinary code that gives the same result every time it runs. AI tools help us with research and drafting, and a human editor approves every story.
Can other newsrooms use the format?
Yes. The standard is published under CC BY 4.0 and the code under the EUPL-1.2. We ask for credit and a link to the standard.
Outlook
The next Living Proof story looks at Irish hospital waiting lists, followed by stories on Irish pharma exports and on how long new medicines take to reach Irish patients. Each will be listed on the Living Proof page with its own archived data file. Living Proof No. 1 will be re-run with a new edition in January 2027.
Sources
- Priya Life Science, The Living Proof Standard, version 1.0, 15 November 2026
- Priya Life Science, Living Proof No. 1: Ireland comes last of 11 countries for trials of medicines, 15 November 2026; data archived at doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24229455
- Press Council of Ireland, Code of Practice, checked 15 November 2026
- International Fact-Checking Network, Code of Principles: the commitments, checked 15 November 2026
- Proof News, About
- The Gamma, Tools for open data-driven storytelling
- S Anand, Add a Verify button, May 2026
- Data2Story, arXiv 2606.11176, June 2026
Cover image: AI-generated illustration.